WHO WE ARE
PURPOSE OF IPRsTrust.org
SUBSCRIPTION
CONTACT
COPYRIGHT & LIABILITY
:
Main Menu
Main menu
Ressources
Academic documents
Law Documents
Standards
3G
SDRAM
Cases
Broadcom vs Qualcomm
Dell
Negotiated Data Solutions
Rambus
Unocal
IPR policies of SSOs
ETSI
IEEE
VITA
Jurisdictions
European Union
Japan
United States
Basics & FAQ
Teaching materials
Events
Home
Academics documents
Document for the thirteenth session of the standing committee on the law of patents
Author:
WIPO Secretariat
Date:
2009
Download
Guideline/Report
Academic documents doc
Chinese experience with global 3G standard setting
Author:
Whalley, John & al.
Date:
2009
Download
Working paper
3G
Academic documents doc
The Application of the Chinese Anti-Monopoly Law To Conduct Involving Intellectual Property Rights
Author:
FENG, Shujie
Date:
2008
Download
Working paper
Chinese Antimonopoly Commission/Agency
Academic documents doc
Patent Holdup, Patent Remedies, and Antitrust Responses
Author:
Cotter, Thomas F.
Date:
2008
Download
Working paper
Academic documents doc
Price Abuses by Essential Patent Holders in a Standard-setting Context: A View From Europe
Author:
Geradin, Damien
Date:
2008
Download
Working paper
Discrimination
Market power (IP holders)
RAND/FRAND
Abuse of dominant position/Article 82
Article 81
Article 82
European Commission
EU
EC Investigation of Rambus
Academic documents doc
Abuse of Dominance and Licensing of Intellectual Property
Author:
Rey, Patrick and D. Salant
Date:
2008
Download
Working paper
Double marginalization/multiple marginalization/royalty stacking
Patent pool
RAND/FRAND
Academic documents doc
Distinguishing Lost Profits from Reasonable Royalties
Author:
Mark A. Lemley
Date:
2008
Download
Working paper
RAND/FRAND
Academic documents doc
Evolving Technologies and Standards Regulation
Author:
Cabral, Luis and David Salant
Date:
2008
Download
Working paper
2G
3G
CDMA
EVDO/CDMA2000
GSM
UMTS
WCDMA
ETSI
ITU
Academic documents doc
Early commitments help patent pool formation
Author:
Lévêque, Francois and Yann Ménière
Date:
2008
Download
Working paper
Double marginalization/multiple marginalization/royalty stacking
Hold-up
Market power (IP holders)
Patent pool
RAND/FRAND
Academic documents doc
Making the World Safe for Standard Setting
Author:
Philip J. Weiser
Date:
2008
Download
Working paper
Academic documents doc
Holdup, Royalty Stacking, and the Presumption of Injunctive Relief for Patent Infringement: A Reply to Lemley and Shapiro, Minnesota Law Review, Vol. 92, No. 3, pp. 714-748
Author:
Sidak, J. Gregory
Date:
2008
Download
Published article
Rambus
Double marginalization/multiple marginalization/royalty stacking
Hold-up
Injunction
Market power (IP holders)
Patent ambush/ambush
Patent misuse
RAND/FRAND
Sherman Act Section 2
FTC
USA
eBay, Inc. v. MercExchange, L.L.C.,
In the Matter of Rambus, Inc.
Academic documents doc
FRANDly fire: are industry standards doing more harm than good? Journal of Intellectual Property Law & Practice, Vol. 3, No. 1 pp. 22-29
Author:
Treacy, Pat and Sophie Lawrance
Date:
2007
Download
Published article
Academic documents doc
Technology standards, Patents and Antitrust, forthcoming in COmpetition and Regulation in Newtork Industries
Author:
Lévêque, Francois and Yann Ménière
Date:
2007
Download
Published article
3G
DVD
MPEG2
SDRAM
VL-BUS
WCDMA
Broadcom
Dell
Nokia
Qualcomm
Rambus
JEDEC
ETSI
VITA
Deceptive conduct
Disclosure
Discrimination
Double marginalization/multiple marginalization/royalty stacking
Essential/essentiality [of patent?]
Ex ante auction
Ex ante negotiations/competition
Hold-out
Hold-up
Market power (IP holders)
Patent ambush/ambush
Patent pool
RAND/FRAND
Abuse of dominant position/Article 82
Article 82
Collusion/Cartel
Foreclosure
Sherman Act Section 2
European Commission
FTC
EU
USA
Academic documents doc
Formulas for fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory royalty determination
Author:
Salant, D.
Date:
2007
Download
Working paper
Ex ante auction
Ex ante negotiations/competition
RAND/FRAND
Academic documents doc
The interplay between IP rights and competition law in the context of standardization, 2 Journal of Intellectual Property Law & Practice, 666-681
Author:
Staniszewski, Piotr
Date:
2007
Download
Published article
ETSI
Deceptive conduct
Disclosure
Patent ambush/ambush
RAND/FRAND
Article 81
Article 82
EU
Germany
USA
In the Matter of Dell Computer Corp
In the Matter of Rambus, Inc.
Rambus v. Infineon
Academic documents doc
The Logic and Limits of Ex Ante Competition in a Standard-Setting Environment, Antitrust Law Journal, forthcoming
Author:
Geradin, Damien and Anne Layne-Farrar
Date:
2007
Download
Published article
ETSI
VITA
Double marginalization/multiple marginalization/royalty stacking
Ex ante auction
Ex ante negotiations/competition
Hold-up
Market power (IP buyers)
Market power (IP holders)
Patent misuse
RAND/FRAND
Article 81
Sherman Act Section 1
Sherman Act Section 2
EU
USA
Academic documents doc
IP Law and Antitrust Law Complementarity when Property Rights are incomplete
Author:
A. Nicita, M. Rizzolli, M.A. Rossi
Download
Working paper
EU
USA
Academic documents doc
Standard Setting, Patents, and Hold-Up, Antitrust Law Journal
Author:
Farrell, Joseph, John Hayes, Carl Shapiro, and Theresa Sullivan
Date:
2007
Download
Published article
3G
SDRAM
UMTS
VL-BUS
WCDMA
Broadcom
Dell
Motorola
Nokia
Qualcomm
Rambus
Unocal
ANSI
CARB
ETSI
IEEE
ITU
JEDEC
VESA
VITA
ANSI
ETSI
IEEE
ITU
JEDEC
VESA
VITA
Cross-licensing
Deceptive conduct
Disclosure
Discrimination
Ex ante negotiations/competition
Hold-up
Market power (IP holders)
Patent ambush/ambush
Patent misuse
RAND/FRAND
Abuse of dominant position/Article 82
EU TTBER
Sherman Act Section 1
Sherman Act Section 2
DOJ
European Commission
FTC
EU
USA
Broadcom v. Qualcomm (Antitrust)
Golden bridge v. Nokia
In the Matter of Dell Computer Corp
In the Matter of Rambus, Inc.
In the Matter of Union Oil Co. of California (Unocal)
Academic documents doc
Ten Things to do about Patents holdup of standards (and one Not to), 48 Boston College Law Review 149
Author:
Lemley, Mark A.
Date:
2007
Download
Published article
Double marginalization/multiple marginalization/royalty stacking
Essential/essentiality [of patent?]
Ex ante negotiations/competition
Hold-up
Injunction
Market power (IP holders)
Patent fragmentation
RAND/FRAND
USA
eBay, Inc. v. MercExchange, L.L.C.,
Academic documents doc
Patent Holdup and Royalty Stacking, 85 Texas Law Review 1991
Author:
Lemley, Mark A. and Carl Shapiro
Date:
2007
Download
Published article
3G
EVDO/CDMA2000
WCDMA
WI-FI
ETSI
IEEE
Double marginalization/multiple marginalization/royalty stacking
Ex ante negotiations/competition
Hold-up
Injunction
Market power (IP holders)
RAND/FRAND
Georgia-Pacific v. United States Plywood
In the Matter of Rambus, Inc.
Academic documents doc
Reply: Patent Holdup and Royalty Stacking
Author:
Lemley, Mark A. and Carl Shapiro
Date:
2007
Download
Published article
Discrimination
RAND/FRAND
Academic documents doc
The Standards Development Organization Advancement Act of 2004: A Victory for Consumer Choice?, 12 Journal of Technology Law and Policy 45
Author:
Topic, Matthew
Date:
2007
Download
Published article
Academic documents doc
Standardization in the ICT Sector: the (Complex) Interface Between Antitrust and Intellectual Property, 15 Economics of Innovation and New Technology, 543,554
Author:
Calderini, Mario and Andrea Giannaccari
Date:
2006
Download
Published article
DOJ
European Commission
FTC
EU
USA
Academic documents doc
The structure and the evolution of essential patents for standards: Lessons from three IT standards, IIR Working Paper WP06-08
Author:
Nagaoka, Sadao, Shimbo Tomoyuki and Naotoshi Tsukada
Date:
2006
Download
Working paper
3G
DVD
MPEG2
WCDMA
ETSI
Patent fragmentation
Strategic patenting
3G doc
Academic documents doc
Patent pools and non-assertion agreements: coordination mechanisms for multi-party IPR holders in standardization
Author:
Rudi Bekkers
Date:
2006
Download
Working paper
2G
3G
DVD
GSM
ISO/IEC DIS 29500
MPEG2
UMTS
WCDMA
ETSI
IEEE
Essential/essentiality [of patent?]
Ex ante royalty free licensing
Patent pool
RAND/FRAND
Collusion/Cartel
EU TTBER
DOJ
European Commission
FTC
Academic documents doc
Injunctions, Hold-Up, and Patent Royalties
Author:
Shapiro, Carl
Date:
2006
Download
Working paper
Ex ante negotiations/competition
Hold-up
Market power (IP holders)
Patent ambush/ambush
RAND/FRAND
Academic documents doc
The Rules of Standard Setting Organizations: an Empirical Analysis, The RAND Journal of Economics, 2007.
Author:
Lerner, Josh, Marcin Strojwas, and Jean Tirole
Date:
2006
Download a
working paper version
Published article
SDRAM
VL-BUS
Dell
Rambus
JEDEC
Disclosure
Ex ante royalty free licensing
RAND/FRAND
Academic documents doc
Standardization and Technological Innovation: Some Reflections on Ex-ante Licensing, FRAND, and the Proper Means to Reward Innovators
Author:
Geradin, Damien
Date:
2006
Download
Published article
ETSI
ETSI
Cross-licensing
Disclosure
Double marginalization/multiple marginalization/royalty stacking
Ex ante auction
Ex ante maximum commitments (other than RAND/royalty free)
Ex ante negotiations/competition
Hold-up
Patent fragmentation
RAND/FRAND
Academic documents doc
Explaining the Increase in Intellectual Property Disclosure, In: Sheri Bolin (editor). The Standards Edge: Golden Mean. Ann Arbor, Mich.: Bolin Communications.
Author:
Simcoe, Timothy S.
Date:
2005
Download
Published article
ANSI
ETSI
IEEE
IETF
ITU
W3C/WWWC
In the Matter of Dell Computer Corp
In the Matter of Rambus, Inc.
Academic documents doc
Open Standards and Intellectual Property Rights, in H. Chesbrough and J. West (eds.) Open Innovation: Researching a New Paradigm: Oxford University Press.
Author:
Simcoe, Timothy S.
Date:
2005
Download
Published article
Dell
Rambus
IEEE
IETF
JEDEC
VESA
W3C/WWWC
IEEE
JEDEC
VESA
W3C/WWWC
defacto standard
RAND/FRAND
DOJ
FTC
In the Matter of Dell Computer Corp
In the Matter of Rambus, Inc.
Academic documents doc
Why Antitrust Should Defer to the Intellectual Property Rules of Standard-Setting Organizations: A Commentary on Teece & Sherry, Minnesota Law Review, Vol. 87, p. 2019
Author:
Carrier, Michael A.
Date:
2005
Download
Published article
Disclosure
Ex ante negotiations/competition
Hold-out
Hold-up
Market power (IP holders)
RAND/FRAND
Sherman Act Section 1
Sherman Act Section 2
Academic documents doc
Intellectual Property and Consortium Standard Patent Pools, Journal of Intellectual Property Rights, 10(3), pp. 206-213
Author:
Aoki, Reiko
Date:
2005
Download
Published article
Double marginalization/multiple marginalization/royalty stacking
Hold-out
Patent pool
Academic documents doc
Substituting Complements, 2 Journal of Competition Law and Economics, 333
Author:
Dari-Mattiacci, Giuseppe and Francesco Parisi
Date:
2005
Download
Published article
Double marginalization/multiple marginalization/royalty stacking
Market power (IP holders)
Patent pool
Academic documents doc
Probabilistic Patents Journal of Economic Perspectives, Volume 19, No 2, Pages 75-98
Author:
Lemley, Mark A. and Carl Shapiro
Date:
2005
Download
Published article
Strategic patenting
USA
Academic documents doc
Standard Setting, Patents and Access Lock-In: RAND Licensing and the Theory of the Firm, Indiana Law Review, Vol. 40
Author:
Miller, Joseph S.
Date:
2005
Download
Published article
ANSI
ANSI
defacto standard
Discrimination
Hold-up
Injunction
Patent misuse
RAND/FRAND
Academic documents doc
Concerted Buying Power: Its Potential for Addressing the Patent Holdup Problem in Standard Setting, 72 Antitrust Law Journal 727, 737
Author:
Skitol, Robert A.
Date:
2005
Download
Published article
Academic documents doc
Reasonable and Nondiscriminatory (RAND) Royalties, Standards Selection, and Control of Market Power 73 Antitrust Law Journal 1, 5
Author:
Swanson, Daniel G. and William J. Baumol
Date:
2005
Download
Published article
Deceptive conduct
Disclosure
Ex ante auction
Ex ante negotiations/competition
Hold-up
Market power (IP holders)
RAND/FRAND
Foreclosure
Academic documents doc
The Consortium Standard and Patent Pools, The Economic Review, 55(4), pp. 346-356
Author:
Aoki, Reiko and Sadao Nagaoka
Date:
2004
Download
Published article
3G
DVD
MPEG2
Double marginalization/multiple marginalization/royalty stacking
Ex ante negotiations/competition
Hold-out
Market power (IP holders)
Patent fragmentation
Patent pool
RAND/FRAND
Academic documents doc
Efficient Patent Pools American Economic Review, vol. 94, n°3, p. 691-711.
Author:
Lerner, Josh and Jean Tirole
Date:
2004
Download a
working paper version
Published article
Double marginalization/multiple marginalization/royalty stacking
Grant back
Hold-out
Market power (IP holders)
Academic documents doc
Antitrust for Patent Pools: A Century of Policy Evolution, Stanford Technology Law Review
Author:
Gilbert, Richard J.
Date:
2004
Download
Published article
DVD
MPEG2
Patent fragmentation
Patent pool
Sherman Act Section 1
DOJ
FTC
USA
Academic documents doc
There is a Better Way: It's Time to Overhaul the Model for Participation in Private Standard-Setting, 12 Journal of Intellectual Property Law 163, 203-09
Author:
Webb, Robert M.
Date:
2004
Download
Published article
Academic documents doc
Antitrust Analysis of Patent Settlements Between Rivals, Antitrust Magazine, Summer 2003
Author:
Shapiro, Carl
Date:
2003
Download
Published article
USA
Academic documents doc
Latent dangers in a patent pool: the European Commission s approval of the 3G wireless technology licensing agreements, 91 California Law Review 1693
Author:
Franziger, Michael R.
Date:
2003
Download
Published article
Academic documents doc
Compulsory Licensing of Technology and the Essential Facilities Doctrine Information Economics and Policy, 16, pp. 13-29
Author:
Aoki, Reiko and John Small
Date:
2002
Download
Published article
Essential/essentiality [of patent?]
Abuse of dominant position/Article 82
Essential facility
Foreclosure
Academic documents doc
Intellectual Property Rights and Standard-Setting Organizations, 90 California Law Review. 1889, 1904-06
Author:
Lemley, Mark A.
Date:
2002
Download
Published article
VL-BUS
Dell
Rambus
ANSI
ETSI
IEEE
IETF
ISO
ITU
JEDEC
VITA
W3C/WWWC
ANSI
ETSI
IEEE
IETF
ISO
ITU
JEDEC
W3C/WWWC
Disclosure
Ex ante royalty free licensing
RAND/FRAND
Sherman Act Section 2
Rambus v. Infineon
Academic documents doc
Patent Misuse Through the Capture of Industry Standards, 17 Berkeley Technology Law Review, 623
Author:
Mueller, Janice M.
Date:
2002
Download
Published article
SDRAM
VL-BUS
Dell
Unocal
CARB
ITU
JEDEC
W3C/WWWC
defacto standard
Ex ante royalty free licensing
Hold-up
Market power (IP holders)
Patent misuse
RAND/FRAND
FTC Act Section 5
Sherman Act Section 2
FTC
USA
In the Matter of Dell Computer Corp
In the Matter of Union Oil Co. of California (Unocal)
Academic documents doc
Inventions, Industry Standards, and Intellectual Property, 17 Berkeley Technology Law Review 1043, 1056-73
Author:
Patterson, Mark R.
Date:
2002
Download
Published article
Dell
Rambus
Unocal
ANSI
CARB
JEDEC
ANSI
defacto standard
Patent misuse
RAND/FRAND
FTC
USA
In the Matter of Dell Computer Corp
In the Matter of Union Oil Co. of California (Unocal)
Academic documents doc
Navigating the Patent Thicket: Cross Licenses, Patent Pools and Standard Setting, in Innovation Policy and the Economy, Adam Jaffe, Joshua Lerner, and Scott Stern, eds., National Bureau of Economics
Author:
Shapiro, Carl
Date:
2001
Download
Published article
DVD
MPEG2
VL-BUS
Motorola
ITU
VESA
Cross-licensing
Double marginalization/multiple marginalization/royalty stacking
Hold-up
Patent misuse
Patent pool
Business Review Letters
Collusion/Cartel
Sherman Act Section 2
DOJ
FTC
USA
In the Matter of Dell Computer Corp
Academic documents doc
Intellectual property rights, strategic technology agreements and market structure : The case of GSM
Author:
Bekkers, Rudi, Duysters, Geert, Verspagen, Bart
Date:
2000
Download
Published article
Strategic patenting
Academic documents doc
European Standards for Mobile Communications : The Tense Relationship between Standards and Intellectual Property Rights
Author:
Bekkers, Rudi, Liotard, Isabelle
Date:
1999
Download
Published article
Academic documents doc
Can Patents Deter Innovation? The Anticommons in Biomedical Research, Science, Vol. 280. no. 5364, pp. 698-701[32]
Author:
Heller, Michael A. and Rebecca S. Eisenberg
Date:
1998
Download
Published article
Double marginalization/multiple marginalization/royalty stacking
Patent fragmentation
Academic documents doc
Antitrust Issues in the Licensing of Intellectual Property: The Nine No-No's Meet the Nineties in Richard Gilbert, Carl Shapiro, Louis Kaplow, Robert Gertner (Ed.), Brookings Papers on Economic Activity. Microeconomics
Author:
Gilbert, Richard and Carl Shapiro
Date:
1997
Download from
JSTOR
Published article
Discrimination
Market power (IP holders)
Patent misuse
Patent pool
Abuse of dominant position/Article 82
Foreclosure
Sherman Act Section 1
Sherman Act Section 2
FTC
USA
Academic documents doc
